These Boots Were Made for Walkin’ – how to choose the right hiking footwear??

The first thing to get straight is that there is no such thing as the perfect footwear!

Choosing hiking/walking footwear is so individual that you really need to ignore 50% of what people tell you and choose the footwear that suits you best.

Now we have that out of the road, here are my tips and tricks, and you can ignore me too!

Scarpa Nangpa-la GTX womens boot
My Scarpa Boots – bright, shiny and new. Source:

I have developed the dot points below after walking over 3 500km through Spain, Portugal and Italy. I have had my fair share of blisters along the way and have come to the realisation that for me, blisters are just part of the settling in process as I start out on a long walk. It is my body’s way of telling me “You’ve got to be kidding?!!

So, here we go:

  • Personal Preference: Just to reinforce, there is no right or wrong answer when comes to footwear and it is important that you choose footwear that suits your foot and your walking plans. When I did the Camino Frances in 2013, I saw every known type of footwear including people walking in socks and sandals and lightweight espadrille-type slip-on shoes. I may have scoffed at the time, but more often than not, they left me in their dust. So, it obviously worked for them.
  • Get Professionally Fitted: Whatever you choose to put on your feet, buy them from a reputable outlet and from staff who know what they are talking about. I got very bad advice before my first Camino, bought boots off the shelf from a standard sports store and proceeded to lose multiple toe nails and develop massive blisters. Compeed became my best friend! For the second Camino, I got my boots fitted by a specialist at Paddy Pallin and the process included walking up and down a steep wooden structure in the store to see how my foot moved in the boot.
Worn out hiking boots and pink-striped socks
…and after…

It is possible that you will pay more for your shoes buying them from a reputable outdoor store, but the advice and professional input is worth it. Consider it an investment in your enjoyment of the walk. There is nothing more demoralising or exhausting that tired and sore feet for every step of 25km.

 Of course the internet is a great source of information and advice too and you can find some good footwear clips on YouTube.

  • Footwear Lacing Tips and Tricks: Buying shoes from someone more knowledgeable than myself was also a benefit because I was shown a clever lacing technique that vastly reduced the movement of my foot and improved the fit of the boot. Have a look at my lacing post to learn how to remove the vertical sliding/lifting movement of your foot in a boot.
  • Boots vs Shoes: Some people swear by hiking shoes, other prefer boots. I am a ‘boot’ girl as I like the extra support provided all over my foot, but especially my ankle. Somehow it just feels more secure and protective. Naturally a hiking shoe is a lighter option, easier to get on and off, and would probably dry quicker too if they got wet.
  • John Muir quote about hiking vs sauntering
    A bit of walking philosophy for you…

    Sizing: Seriously consider buying your walking footwear 1-1.5 sizes larger than your normal, everyday shoes. With all those steps and daily pounding, and if it is hot, your feet do swell and it is important that there is space in your footwear for that to happen unobstructed. Again, I didn’t know that would happen on my first camino and came unstuck Big Time. If you wear orthotics, this is even more important as they take up additional space in the shoe and are an extra source of friction.

  • Weight: In the excitement of your shoe shopping you may not think about the weight of the shoes. Some boots can weigh up to 1kg. While that doesn’t seem like a lot at the beginning of each day, believe me after 25km it makes a big difference.

Also consider packing another light pair of shoes or sandals to change into at the end of the day. These need to be supportive with plenty of cushioning to help your feet recover.

Keen sandals
Keen sandals – not pretty but comfy! Source:

In my opinion Keen-type sandals are ideal as they still offer protection to your feet as you explore the cobblestone streets of an ancient town, but they are light and airy allowing your feet to breathe after being tied up in boots all day. Again, check the weight of these shoes as you don’t need to be carrying extra on your back too!

  • Socks: Like footwear, the type and number of socks you wear is an individual thing. Some people like thick wool socks, other prefer to wear a thin wicking sock under a thick sock (two pairs of socks). My personal preference is one pair of thin wool socks. Again, the additional space (if any) in your shoe will designate what you can wear comfortably.
  • Waterproofing: Unfortunately it is likely that not every day on the trail will be sunny and dry. When you are choosing your footwear, think about how waterproof they will be vs breathability. The more your feet sweat, the increased chance of blisters. Many people swear by removing their shoes and socks every couple hours as they take a break from walking and this allows their feet and socks to dry out. I don’t do this, but perhaps I should try it on my next walk.
  • Training: Whatever footwear you choose, ensure you buy them well in advance of your planned walk and train in them. After you have trained for a while, the shoes become ‘walked-in’ and mould to the shape of your foot. Better quality shoes (possibly reflected in the price) will require less ‘walking-in’. Again on the Camino Frances I saw many people who had taken their bright, shiny, new shoes out of their box for the first time as they packed to leave for Spain and they suffered. Not a good idea!

hiking philosophy quote with a forest backgroundI know I am strange, but there is something very exciting about buying new hiking boots. It is like a whole new adventure arrives in the same box!

For all the dedicated walkers out there, what have I missed?

What are your footwear tips and tricks?


#longdistancewalking #hikinggear #walkingshoes

10 thoughts on “These Boots Were Made for Walkin’ – how to choose the right hiking footwear??

  1. My Dream Garden July 31, 2019 — 8:26 pm

    More great advice, which I will definitely be following next time I buy some walking boots. I’ve only bought expensive boots once- stupidly I didn’t get them fitted, resulting in painful and gruesome damage to my toes which I won’t describe! Anyone planning for a serious walking adventure should read this!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Jane. I find it amazing how hiking/walking makes you reassess your priorities and hone in on the simple things in life. After 25-30km your feet and footwear are No.1 priority….as well as getting your backpack off AND finding a cold beer! Happy walking, Mel

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Ha! You’re not strange … new hiking shoes are exciting. Compeed and the camino lol that reminded me of the pharmacy vending machines all along the camino! No joking matter of course 😉 I didn’t need compeed but did end up with the camino candy in my pocket – ibuprofen (the strong ones). I think your advice about the sandal is good. I bought some hiking sandals for the camino and loved changing into them at night. The mistake I made was they had a thong between the big and first toe … a bummer for wearing socks and sandals. So defo recommend the open toe.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Ahhhh, camino candy! 🙂 How I loved the over-the-counter medication system in Spain! And the price! Not that I am a pill-popper, but those anti-inflammatories are GOLD! 🙂 If only I had better Spanish so I really knew what I was buying! 🙂 Mel


  4. All great advice. It’s hard to find the right hiking boots. I’ve lost a few toenails over the years! Keen sandals are great. I do love hiking in Chacos as long as I have broken them in slowly. I got shin splints one time because I did a 10 mile hike with him before easing into it. Amateur move. Haha.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. We were all amateurs once and thankfully we are quick learners!! Painful lessons, but good ones! Have a good day, Mel


  6. I’ve become a toe sock convert. My little toes tuck under the next toe and have always been a source of painful blisters but my toe socks (I use a liner sock with a normal hiking sock over the top) have been heavenly. Can’t believe how much more comfortably I walk. I’ve also switched to non-waterproof hiking shoes after giving my boots away at the end of my last trip to Nepal. I’m really enjoying the lighter experience. I think you have to be careful with sizing. I take an 8.5 in my running shoes but my Salomons are only an 8 and are comfortable with the two socks. If your shoes are too big, you’re going to be prone to tripping. As you’ve said, best to buy from the experts and try them on.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Isn’t it funny how we are all different? I am still a ‘single-pair-of-thin-wool’ walker, but on the next walk (the GOW) I am going to experiment with taking my socks and boots off when we have a break. I am hoping that will give my feet a chance to cool and dry out and avoid blisters…. Maybe I am being an optimist?? 😉

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I have heard that doing that can help so it’s definitely worth trying. Fingers crossed for no blisters!

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I saw many people doing this when I walked caminos in Spain and Portugal. Now it is my turn to give it a whirl.

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close